Depends on what you want it for. I have a 4in. barreled 629 for CCW and it`s great for that. I also have a Super Red Hawk in .454 that I plan to start useing as a walk around gun for deer hunting. It wears a 2X Leupold scope. For a hunting gun I lean towards the Red Hawk of the 2 you named, but both will surve you well.
__________________
Catfish
|