To peep or not to peep, that is the question.

[Rustywreck]

peeps come with different size apetures. Maybe you happened to get a medium or small sized peep.
I use an 1/8th peep.
If you have a short bow and a longer draw length, it can actually make a large peep appear small because of the angle of the string.
Check out Super Peeps. They make peeps angled for different length bows.
There are so many options available in sights that don't require a peep, and different kinds of peeps that I'm sure you can find something right for you. It may take some looking though.
I can tell you that with a 1/8" peep, I can see the entire deer at 20 yards.